An independent agency built on trust, not transactions.

Local roots, a wider reach.

Port Bay Insurance began with a simple frustration: insurance was being sold, not explained. Our founder set out to build an agency that would put people first — comparing the whole market instead of pushing one company’s products, and taking the time to make sure clients actually understood what they were buying.

Two decades later, that principle hasn’t changed. What started as a single storefront in Sheridan now serves families and businesses across Wyoming, Montana, Colorado, Idaho, and beyond — still independent, still local at heart, and still answering to our clients above all.

Whether you’re enrolling in a first health plan, sorting out Medicare, or protecting a new car, we’re the steady, knowledgeable guide in your corner — before, during, and long after you sign.